Subscriptions & Membership

Appstle vs Subscribfy: Memberships and Subscriptions

By Subscribfy Team

1 min

Three Appstle apps against one Subscribfy app: published pricing, member limits, store credit, wallet pass and who each one fits, for Shopify brands choosing a membership.

Appstle vs Subscribfy for memberships: discount perks and a 750-member top plan vs a membership fee returned as store credit

Free for Shopify brands: your paid membership plan, modelled on your store, in your inbox within the hour.

Get my free plan
Share

Appstle vs Subscribfy is mostly a question of what you want members to pay for. The short answer: Appstle is the cheaper choice if you need product subscriptions, or a discount-and-free-shipping membership for a few hundred members, with plans from free to $100 a month per app. Subscribfy fits a Shopify brand that wants a paid membership where the monthly fee comes back as store credit, with loyalty, subscriptions, a wallet pass and chargeback alerts in one app.

Not sure which model your store needs? Get your free membership plan: perks, pricing logic and a year-one estimate for your store, in your inbox within the hour.

Appstle vs Subscribfy: what is the real difference?

Appstle sells three separate Shopify apps (Subscriptions, Memberships and Loyalty), each with its own plan and its own limits. Subscribfy is one app that runs a store credit membership, loyalty points, product subscriptions, a wallet pass and chargeback alerts from the same customer record.

That split matters more than any single feature. With Appstle, a membership that gives members a discount sits in the Memberships app, while store credit and points sit in the Loyalty app. Two installs, two bills, two sets of settings to keep in sync.

The membership model is the second difference. Appstle Memberships describes its perks as discounted pricing, shipping benefits and access, the Amazon Prime pattern its own listing names. Subscribfy is built around the credit-first model: the member pays a monthly fee and gets it back as store credit, plus perks. The fee feels like money already spent in your store, not a charge for a discount.

Appstle vs Subscribfy compared: pricing, limits and features

The table uses each app's Shopify App Store listing as published in November 2026. Appstle publishes every plan price. Subscribfy lists a free plan and paid plans with guided setup.


Appstle

Subscribfy

Apps to install

3 (Subscriptions, Memberships, Loyalty)

1

Paid membership pricing

Free up to 25 members; $19/month up to 100; $39/month up to 500; $79/month up to 750; enterprise on request

Free plan available; paid plans with guided setup

Membership perks

Discounted pricing, shipping benefits, gated access

Monthly store credit, percentage discounts, exclusive perks, VIP and Elite tiers

Store credit

In the Loyalty app (free up to 250 orders a month, then $10 to $100/month by order volume)

Built into the membership; unused credit can expire or convert to a gift card

Product subscriptions

Subscriptions app: free up to $500/month of subscription revenue, $100/month up to $100,000

Included: subscribe and save, subscription boxes, prepaid plans

Apple and Google Wallet pass

Not listed

Yes, shows tier and store credit balance

Chargeback alerts

Not listed

Yes, Visa and Mastercard dispute alerts

Shopify POS

Yes

Yes

App Store rating

Subscriptions 5.0 (9,312 reviews), Memberships 5.0 (953), Loyalty 5.0 (1,488)

5.0 (21 reviews)

On the App Store since

April 2021 (Subscriptions)

September 2022

Sources: Shopify App Store listings for Appstle Memberships, Appstle Subscriptions, Appstle Loyalty and Subscribfy; Subscribfy features from its membership and store credit documentation.

Read two rows first. The member limit: Appstle's highest published Memberships plan stops at 750 memberships, which a brand doing $3M a year can pass in a few months if the offer converts. And the review count: Appstle has thousands of reviews across its apps, Subscribfy has 21. Appstle's track record on the App Store is longer, and that is a fair point in its favor.

Want to see what a store credit membership would look like on your own product pages, with your prices? Get your free membership plan and compare it with the Appstle setup you are pricing.

When is Appstle enough?

Appstle is enough when subscriptions are your main recurring revenue, your membership is a discount club for a few hundred people, or the budget is the deciding factor. At those sizes its flat prices are hard to beat, and it charges no transaction fee on the Subscriptions plans.

  1. You sell replenishment products. Coffee, supplements, pet food. Appstle Subscriptions covers subscribe and save, build-a-box and payment retries, and its pricing grows with subscription revenue, not with your total sales.

  2. Your membership is a Prime-style discount. 10% off and free shipping for a yearly fee. Appstle Memberships handles the billing, tagging and member portal for $79 a month or less.

  3. You expect under 750 members. That is the ceiling on Appstle's published Memberships plans. Above it, you talk to their sales team.

When does Subscribfy earn more than Appstle?

Subscribfy earns more when the membership itself is the retention strategy: a monthly fee that turns into store credit, so members come back to spend money they already paid. This is the model the Subscribfy founders ran for 10 years at Adore Me before building the app.

The numbers come from brands with no natural subscription product. At Tres Colori, a jewelry brand, 54% of shoppers opt into the Tres VIP membership and 51% of total revenue now comes from members, per the Tres Colori case study. Nailboo built a discovery membership instead of auto-ship: 62% of shoppers joined, members bring 60% of revenue, and their LTV is 101% higher after 11 months, per the Nailboo case study.

Scale is the other case. Dossier's membership counts close to 50,000 active members with a 125% higher LTV after 12 months, per the Dossier case study. A member base that size sits far beyond the 750-member top tier Appstle publishes.

The rest of the stack follows the same customer. Members see their tier and credit balance on a wallet pass for Shopify, earn points in the same app, and the same platform sends Visa and Mastercard dispute alerts before a chargeback lands.

How to choose between Appstle and Subscribfy

Start from the member you want in a year, then count the apps you would need to serve them. If the answer is one subscription app and a discount club, Appstle is the lean choice. If it is a paid membership with store credit, points and a wallet card, you want one system holding that data.

Two quick tests help. First, multiply your monthly orders by your expected opt-in rate: if the result is above 750 within a year, check Appstle's enterprise pricing before you commit. Second, ask what members get for their fee. A discount trains customers to wait for a discount. Store credit gives them a balance to spend, and Riversol's members have used 58% of the store credit issued to them, per the Riversol case study.

For a full look at Appstle's three apps on their own, read our Appstle Shopify review. If you run a beauty or skincare store on Shopify Plus, the paid membership buyer's guide for beauty brands compares more options.

Frequently asked questions

Is Appstle free?

Each Appstle app has a free plan with a cap: Memberships is free up to 25 memberships, Subscriptions up to $500 a month of subscription revenue, and Loyalty up to 250 orders a month, per their Shopify App Store listings.

Does Appstle Memberships give members store credit?

Appstle's Memberships listing describes perks as discounted pricing, shipping benefits and access. Store credit appears in Appstle's separate Loyalty app. In Subscribfy, store credit is the core of the membership: the monthly fee is returned to the member as credit.

Does Subscribfy do product subscriptions like Appstle?

Yes. Subscribfy includes subscribe and save, subscription boxes and prepaid plans in the same app as the membership, so a customer can be a member and a subscriber on one account.

Which is better for a Shopify Plus brand doing over $3M a year?

It depends on the program. For a subscriptions-first brand, Appstle Subscriptions is a solid, low-cost option. For a brand that wants a paid membership to drive repeat purchases at scale, Subscribfy's store credit model and one-app setup fit better.

Pick the model before the app

Appstle and Subscribfy both work on Shopify. The choice comes down to whether you want members paying for a discount, or paying for credit they will come back to spend.

Get your free membership plan: the perks, the pricing logic and a year-one estimate for your store, in your inbox within the hour. Prefer to talk it through? Book 30 minutes with our CEO and bring your order volume and your current Appstle setup.

Ask AI about this article
Share

FREE · IN YOUR INBOX WITHIN THE HOUR

See what a paid membership would add to your store

Send us your store URL. We model your year-one revenue from a membership, design the program, and show it on your own product page and cart.

What is Subscribfy?

A retention suite for Shopify Plus brands. Memberships, subscriptions, loyalty, and analytics in one platform, built directly for Shopify.

•

Memberships with store credit, perks, and early access

•

Product subscriptions designed to reduce churn

•

Loyalty and chargeback protection in the same suite

Get my free plan

Image

Book a meeting with our sales team now!

Create predictable revenue from the customers you already have.