LoyaltyLion Alternatives for Shopify Brands in 2026

LoyaltyLion is a loyalty platform made for Shopify and Shopify Plus, with points, tiers, referrals and a customizable loyalty page. Brands look for a LoyaltyLion alternative for different reasons: price as order volume grows, a feature tied to a higher plan, or a different model altogether.

This page covers what LoyaltyLion offers, the main alternatives on Shopify, and how to choose. Facts come from each company’s own website, help center or Shopify App Store listing, checked in October 2026.

What does LoyaltyLion do well?

LoyaltyLion gives Shopify brands a points and tiers program with a loyalty page you can restyle in its Theme Editor, Shopify POS support, and on Shopify Plus, gift card rewards, redemption at checkout and a Shopify Flow connector.

Its help center also describes a Recharge integration that can place subscribers in an exclusive tier, with availability depending on plan. If those features match your program, switching may not be worth it.

What are the main LoyaltyLion alternatives?

The main LoyaltyLion alternatives on Shopify are Smile.io, Yotpo Loyalty, Okendo and Rivo for points-based programs, and a paid membership like Subscribfy’s when you want commitment rather than points.

1. Smile.io. Points, VIP tiers and referrals, with a Loyalty Hub in customer accounts and redemption at checkout for Shopify Plus on its Growth plan, per its listing. Compared in detail in Smile.io vs LoyaltyLion.

2. Yotpo. Loyalty sold alongside Yotpo’s reviews and SMS products; its reviews app connects to loyalty, per its listing. See Yotpo vs Subscribfy.

3. Okendo. Reviews, surveys, quizzes, referrals and loyalty in one platform, per its listing.

4. Rivo. Loyalty, referrals, cashback and memberships, with more than 50 integrations, according to Rivo.

5. Subscribfy. Loyalty (points, credits, cashback, referrals and tiers) next to paid membership and product subscriptions in one app. Loyalty plans start at $99 a month for up to 500 monthly orders, per its loyalty page.

How do you choose a LoyaltyLion alternative?

1. Price it at next year’s order volume. Several loyalty apps, including LoyaltyLion and Subscribfy, price by monthly orders, so the cheap plan today may not be the cheap plan in 12 months.

2. Check where members redeem. On Shopify Plus, redemption inside checkout is available from several vendors; on other plans it usually happens before checkout.

3. Plan the points migration. Decide how existing balances move and tell members before the switch.

For Shopify Plus specifics, see our checklist of loyalty solutions for Shopify Plus.

When is another points program not the answer?

Swapping one points app for another doesn’t change how points behave. Antavo’s Global Customer Loyalty Report 2026 found that 26.2% of loyalty points go unspent and 11.9% expire unspent (Business Wire release).

A paid membership works differently: the customer pays a monthly fee and gets it back as store credit, so they have a reason to return. It can sit next to your points program. Dossier kept its loyalty program and added a VIP membership; more than 200,000 shoppers joined and members show a 125% higher LTV after 12 months (case study).

Thinking of leaving LoyaltyLion? Bring your monthly orders and repeat rate to a 30-minute call. We’ll compare the cost of switching with adding a paid membership next to what you have. Book a call with Subscribfy.

Frequently asked questions

Does LoyaltyLion work with Shopify POS?

Yes. LoyaltyLion’s website says it integrates with Shopify POS for online and in-store loyalty.

Can I move my LoyaltyLion points to another app?

Usually yes, by exporting balances and importing them into the new app. Ask the new vendor how it handles the import before you switch.

Is there a LoyaltyLion alternative with paid membership?

Yes. Subscribfy runs paid membership and loyalty in one app, and Rivo also offers memberships.

Want a second opinion on your loyalty setup? Book a 30-minute strategy call.